RT @dnunan79: @JeremyHowick @alf_collins The problem is one of implementation - AND THEN APPROPRIATE EVALUATION The latter is where I have…
RT @dnunan79: @alf_collins @JeremyHowick Yes. Tough indeed. When we do have evidence for “brief”, even that is more complex than would seem…
@alf_collins @JeremyHowick Yes. Tough indeed. When we do have evidence for “brief”, even that is more complex than would seem: https://t.co/BFLML5AyFP Whether asking GPs to crack it at the individual patient level is also an important question. Decades o
@JeremyHowick @alf_collins The problem is one of implementation - AND THEN APPROPRIATE EVALUATION The latter is where I have turned my attention. 20 years of initiatives (& ££) to promote PA through GP/primary care but with little proper evaluation.
@Jennife10651535 @MaggieMossop @RslewisSally @degampraesident @RichardLehman1 This preventn malarkey is being taken 2 extremes & will surely bankrupt the NHS. @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney & @dnblane wrote a wonderful @BJGPjournal articl in 2021 "E
RT @dnunan79: Show me you don’t know much about a field you cite without showing me… “Prefer research evidence over other forms of knowled…
Show me you don’t know much about a field you cite without showing me… “Prefer research evidence over other forms of knowledge…” https://t.co/D7p85NkeLh (see 1:40-2:02) This sort of article is why we wrote this: https://t.co/QVXXMal2XV “traditional” =
RT @dnunan79: The hope/lure of alternative medicine is ever present: https://t.co/8pcCcnDNrg But it's an area where, at best, "evidence-ba…
RT @dnunan79: The hope/lure of alternative medicine is ever present: https://t.co/8pcCcnDNrg But it's an area where, at best, "evidence-ba…
RT @dnunan79: The hope/lure of alternative medicine is ever present: https://t.co/8pcCcnDNrg But it's an area where, at best, "evidence-ba…
The hope/lure of alternative medicine is ever present: https://t.co/8pcCcnDNrg But it's an area where, at best, "evidence-based" often means "reference-based" https://t.co/N2woZUH5to And a good time to re-share our article @mgtmccartney @dnblane https:/
IN THE USA (context: https://t.co/OAyYrMcVCY) And: https://t.co/hcNpF4MD2a
Hi Margaret @mgtmccartney & David @dnunan79 , any updates on this @BJGPjournal article of yours? https://t.co/Bah4YHYg4x . Ur article was critiqued by @BritSocLM https://t.co/mIerSnHbY3 We are getting more and more individual funding requests 4 functio
Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the ‘lifestyle medicine’ movement https://t.co/Bah4YHYg4x via @dnunan79 et al
@statsepi You’ve read this of course. https://t.co/hcNpF4MD2a
@heavyredaction Clearly not much of a research record: https://t.co/xaBvm0Fawr Per Google search, seems to practice "lifestyle medicine," which seems a bit like like old wine in new bottles & even per this, a potential Trojan Horse for bad therapies a
RT @DipeshGopal: @Dr_Ellie Some lifestyle med advocates talking about social prescribing + lifestyle medicine will narrow health inequaliti…
@Dr_Ellie Some lifestyle med advocates talking about social prescribing + lifestyle medicine will narrow health inequalities...it won't. See @andrewmoscrop in @bmj_latest: https://t.co/fG4UTAkHqO See work from @dnunan79 @dnblane @mgtmccartney https://t.c
Bra genomgång av bristerna och de felaktiga påståenden som görs kring det som idag mest brukar kallas för funktionsmedicin i Sverige. Men det här är något som har funnits väldigt länge. Man bara döper om det då och då för att sälja samma sak https://t.co
RT @MedCrisis: Some great additional points in this article/thread @dnunan79 @mgtmccartney https://t.co/wlJbHwUAHv
RT @DipeshGopal: 1/ 🧵 THREAD on critiquing lifestyle medicine from article from @dnunan79 @dnblane @mgtmccartney just published in @BJGP…
RT @MedCrisis: Some great additional points in this article/thread @dnunan79 @mgtmccartney https://t.co/wlJbHwUAHv
RT @DipeshGopal: 1/ 🧵 THREAD on critiquing lifestyle medicine from article from @dnunan79 @dnblane @mgtmccartney just published in @BJGP…
Some great additional points in this article/thread @dnunan79 @mgtmccartney https://t.co/wlJbHwUAHv
RT @dnunan79: “Lifestyle medicine” https://t.co/FaHUemuUKl
“Lifestyle medicine” https://t.co/FaHUemuUKl
RT @mortensode: Der er vælgere i livsstilsmedicin men penge i folkesundhed. Skal sundhedsvæsnet behandle raske vælgere eller syge menneske…
RT @dnunan79: @PhilAlz @pash22 @DrJeffCummings @ProfRobHoward @LonSchneiderMD @seb_walsh @barttels2 @dr_shibley On lifestyle medicine and c…
RT @dnunan79: @PhilAlz @pash22 @DrJeffCummings @ProfRobHoward @LonSchneiderMD @seb_walsh @barttels2 @dr_shibley On lifestyle medicine and c…
@PhilAlz @pash22 @DrJeffCummings @ProfRobHoward @LonSchneiderMD @seb_walsh @barttels2 @dr_shibley On lifestyle medicine and continued focus on the individual: https://t.co/hcNpF4NaRI https://t.co/RKZI1kH63R
@MarkRobinson_Oz @felly500 @spidermaani So much sense! @mgtmccartney @dnblane and I also point to individual framing in our analysis piece on lifestyle medicine “Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse”: https://t.co/hcNpF4NaRI Cited this important revie
RT @HelenRSalisbury: Great article by @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney 'Lifestyle medicine' as a Trojan horse for unevidenced treatments & a dist…
RT @HelenRSalisbury: Great article by @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney 'Lifestyle medicine' as a Trojan horse for unevidenced treatments & a dist…
RT @HelenRSalisbury: Great article by @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney 'Lifestyle medicine' as a Trojan horse for unevidenced treatments & a dist…
RT @dnunan79: This. Joe Rogan doesn’t come with credibility of a medical qualification - which many associate with a) trustworthy & b) sci…
RT @MedCrisis: Nicely put https://t.co/zRzxEpgM8O
Nicely put https://t.co/zRzxEpgM8O
RT @dnunan79: This. Joe Rogan doesn’t come with credibility of a medical qualification - which many associate with a) trustworthy & b) sci…
This. Joe Rogan doesn’t come with credibility of a medical qualification - which many associate with a) trustworthy & b) scientific/critical thinking/“evidence-based” For this reason medics pushing this stuff is bigger issue IMO We wrote about it: h
@RuthTapsell @drtom_butler @PCLifestyleconf @DrScottMurray @lowcarbGP We also have to be mindful of attempts made to piggy-back in pseudoscience and conspiracy on the good intentions of those who want to help patients achieve their health goals. We write
Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the ‘lifestyle medicine’ movement https://t.co/vzFdEG7OaN
RT @BJGPjournal: Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the ‘lifestyle medicine’ movement https://t.co/9b8uKQdJ8S
Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the ‘lifestyle medicine’ movement https://t.co/9b8uKQdJ8S
Good thread on an underlying principle for how society tackles issues where systemic factors play the greatest role. Our @BJGPjournal paper points to this around “Lifestyle Medicine”, where a focus on the individual persists: https://t.co/Xkg1m3O7or
@TimothyEdenRD @RD_Catherine We are on the same page Timothy. https://t.co/hcNpF4MD2a
"Prevention is better than cure." Yes. On so many levels, yes. Can definitely be difficult to implement from a #policy perspective, but oh so important. #healthcare #prevention https://t.co/J1GQOSvu3T
Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the 'lifestyle medicine' movement #Wellness via https://t.co/XqJP2T8ceN https://t.co/JgBhl0Ha0S
Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the 'lifestyle medicine' movement #Wellness via https://t.co/OKauwMPPW1 https://t.co/7Lmb5MzvQe
Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the 'lifestyle medicine' movement #Wellness via https://t.co/Ui3JcQTu6m https://t.co/ehOgnbEUI0
Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the 'lifestyle medicine' movement #Wellness via https://t.co/IphRfqQNu6 https://t.co/2RX8lvgBrC
Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the 'lifestyle medicine' movement #Wellness via https://t.co/PCbMJ7cztH https://t.co/Kng3NI0sjS
Yes! ‘Wellness’ ‘lifestyle’ often used to smuggle bunkum. Beware https://t.co/V1pDcj0AfO
@LornaLLO @drchatterjeeuk @Dr_Ayan @MichaelMarmot Yes 100% agree. Social prescribing touches the surface. If we want health we need to go to the heart of the structures that make up society...far beyond the reach of medicine. cc. @sandrogalea https://
@SimonMDLord @BenJaneFitness On “Lifestyle” in medicine:
RT @dnunan79: Re-reading this & have to say I think we did a good job in raising important issues with 'lifestyle medicine' Interesting re…
Re-reading this & have to say I think we did a good job in raising important issues with 'lifestyle medicine' Interesting responses but would say they lack evidence to refute our key concerns: 1. Pseudoscience infiltration risk 2. Inherent inequalitie
RT @Bill_Vicenzino: individual and community responsibility... Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the ‘lifestyle medici…
individual and community responsibility... Exemplary medical care or Trojan horse? An analysis of the ‘lifestyle medicine’ movement https://t.co/N4suen7XiO https://t.co/Du8xB8k2QY
RT @mgtmccartney: We have written a bit about this here https://t.co/R0i0zfgDsy
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: This is an excellent piece. Physiotherapy has also fallen into the same trap of not critically appraising lifestyle bas…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @mgtmccartney: We have written a bit about this here https://t.co/R0i0zfgDsy
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
“…individual-level interventions are most likely to succeed when integrated with public health interventions, which focus on populations, either within communities or with higher-level (regional/national) policies.” https://t.co/Qimc3lNc49
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
RT @DerekGriffin86: "Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at low…
nice business model?!
Public health problems must be targeted at population level. Helpful thread on the issue of weighing children at school and a link here to a very good analysis in this article on lifestyle medicine.
"Lifestyle medicine’s continued emphasis on the individual as the change agent most likely results in the people at lowest risk having the greatest amount of intervention". https://t.co/xRQmBmtIKR
This is an excellent piece. Physiotherapy has also fallen into the same trap of not critically appraising lifestyle based interventions. Music to my ears to promote moving from individually targeted solutions to looking at wider socioeconomic drivers.
We have written a bit about this here https://t.co/R0i0zfgDsy
Does this include misleading psycho social reseach & abuse of biospychosocial model used in integrated & personalised care , posturing as holistic & parity 4 mental health? Researchers relationships with insurance companies & failure 2 disc
RT @HelenRSalisbury: Great article by @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney 'Lifestyle medicine' as a Trojan horse for unevidenced treatments & a dist…
RT @HelenRSalisbury: Great article by @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney 'Lifestyle medicine' as a Trojan horse for unevidenced treatments & a dist…
RT @HelenRSalisbury: Great article by @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney 'Lifestyle medicine' as a Trojan horse for unevidenced treatments & a dist…
RT @HelenRSalisbury: Great article by @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney 'Lifestyle medicine' as a Trojan horse for unevidenced treatments & a dist…
RT @HelenRSalisbury: Great article by @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney 'Lifestyle medicine' as a Trojan horse for unevidenced treatments & a dist…
RT @HelenRSalisbury: Great article by @dnunan79 & @mgtmccartney 'Lifestyle medicine' as a Trojan horse for unevidenced treatments & a dist…
RT @AudreyBirt: Re public health abs. agree on population action vs personal.easy to blame individuals than political policy eg poverty and…